"Cory -- You misunderstand my position. I've never said that I was certain about anything, much less that I am "certain about not being certain." Nathan is the one who makes a certainty-claim, not me...."

"And as to your unusual claims to have "certainty" about various things, you never responded to MY point -- which was the point raised in the SLATE article at the beginning of this thread, in defense of agnosticism -- of how you reconcile your alleged..."

"You can't be saying that the only meaning of "god" is "a being that is logically inconsistent," can you? That makes no sense...."

"But your argument seems circular. You are saying that "God" MUST be conceived in one specific way only, and that this preferred way leads directly to logical inconsistencies...."

"I don't know why you say "you cannot redefine the terms" -- of course you can, it happens all the time in all kinds of disciplines and debates...."